Aside from the OF picks that have not panned out, there are the pitcher picks of course.
In the last 20 drafts, aside from the great picks that got hurt and the unknown Simpson and the sandwich picks that did not pan out, there is: Pawelek, Brownlie, Christensen, Noel, Jayson Peterson, Ratliff, and Derek Wallace.
Maybe, at this point, we should forget about the history and just deal with the new guy on his own merits.