Looking at it again, I think our scoring system is OK...
Is it possible on CBS (or any fantasy platform) to spread out the complete game and shutout points over the last three innings? So instead of 5 points for a CG and 10 points for a SO, you award those points this way:
- 2 bonus points for finishing the 7th
- 3 bonus points for finishing the 8th
- 5 bonus points for finishing the 9th
- 5 bonus points for throwing a shutout
Since managers only expect 5-6 innings out of most pitchers and complete games are almost non-existent, it just seems like that would be a more accurate way to score in the current game. Right now, the difference between a 6 inning start and an 8 inning start is 2 points. That seems low, because that's a pretty huge difference in real life.
In general, high scoring starting pitcher categories in fantasy just don't accurately capture how starters are used in 2020 (with quality starts being the one exception).