1. Bryant
2. Rizzo
In part because there are FAs available who can replace Baez.
But, how about re-signing all three.
I agree.
If we can only sign one at a reasonable price, I would choose Bryant.
If we can only sign two at a reasonable price, I would choose Bryant and Rizzo.
I would love to keep Baez also, if that were possible.
But under no circumstances should we allow any of them to go into free agency.
Of course, all this ignores the price that it would take to sign them, and what we would have to sacrifice to pay that price(s). I think that in the long run, the most important player to retain is Contreras. And when it comes to value, it may be better to sign Pederson than any of the other three, price and future budgets being taken into account.