Bleacher Bums Forum

A couple of ESPN comments from Giants fans on Schierholtz. 

Thom Zajac · Bonny Doon, California

As I Giants fan I might be able to shed a little light on Schierholtz... He has some tools: good, fast fielder with exceptionally strong arm.. Surprising power and good speed on the bases. Can really get HOT at the plate for stretches.... It seemed as if he was always on the verge of blossoming, but he always seemed to follow a hot streak (he will have those) with a prolonged ice cold streak, interrupted with a minor injury of some sort and then a mysterious loss of power. And here's the thing that kind of drives fans crazy: he's not the smartest player on the block. Has speed but can't steal bases. Has a great arm but often plays too deep to throw runners out at home. Will make some insanely bad running mistakes and throwing decisions. And he'll be unhappy about not playing everyday.... All that said, it wouldn't be a complete shock if he impresses with a.290 average, and 25 homers playing half his games at the Friendly Confines in an everyday role, though I'm sure most Giant fans reading this would bet against that.
Reply · 5 · Like · Follow Post · 12 hours ago

Christophe Silvey · Subscribe · UC Berkeley

Actually, as a Giants fan I would not be surprised. Nate never got a chance to have a 'prolonged' cold streak, unlike someone like, say Brandon Belt, or even Blanco. He went hitless one series in Cincy and was on the bench for the next 6 weeks. Never one of Bochy's 'guys'.

Rondon was out of left field, but I like it. It seems that no other rule 5 pitcher offered his combination of high ceiling (98 mph, excellent control, mid rotation starter) along with his seeming readiness to contribute at the major league level.

Obviously, it all comes down to health, and as others have noted, Cubs seem to like g@mbling on elbow injuries. I've read elsewhere that Hoyerstein think health may be the new market inefficiency, so let's hope they know something others don't with all these bum elbows.

Josh Hamilton was out of left field at the time, too...hope he's a hidden gem!

Pirates re-sign Jason Grilli.

Jesse Rogers ‏@ESPNChiCubs

cross off for cubs RT @JonHeymanCBS: The long wait is over. Pirates re-sign grilli. #sheffield

Now Heyman's backtracking on Grilli.  I guess Gary Sheffield is still shopping him around.

Jon Heyman ‏@JonHeymanCBS

grilli told @Tom_Singer " I have not made a decision. i don't know where these reports are coming from.'' #bucs

I guess he's just as good as anyone else out there.  Maybe it really has been the wrist that has killed his last two seasons.  We'll see.

I'm sure they'll keep looking and would be ok with using him as a backup if they find someone better.  I guess that sets the opening day lineup as something like:

DeJesus
Schierholtz/Sappelt
Castro
Rizzo
Soriano
Stewart
Castillo
Barney

With a big comeback year by Stewart and a breakout season for Castro, this Cubs team could win 70 games.

Ian Stewart does suck but he doesnt suck worse than a lot of the FAs available.

This team is still gonna be horrible.

We might not lose 100 games but I bet we'll lose 90.

Thinking about it we dont even have anybody in the high minors that could come up and make an impact this year other than cats like Junior Lake and Matt Szczur.