Too bad Einstein didn't actually say that "definition of insanity" thing, because it would really fit here.
It just boils down to being too cheap to sign high-velocity relievers with a track record. Going after washed-up former closers and junkballers is inherently fraught with peril.
Signing big ticket relievers is kind of Damned if you do, damned if you don’t proposition.
Biggest ticket free agent relief signings over last three free agent cycles. Lots of disappointments here:
Josh Hader-Tanner Scott-Edwin Diaz-Devin Williams-Robert Suarez-Tyler Rogers-Jeff Hoffman.
Jays not using Hoffman or Rogers to close but minimum salary Louis Varland instead, Hader and Diaz are hurt, Devin Williams mostly a bust, Tanner Scott a bust. Suarez good so far but not closing.
Some Hoyer bullpen decisions poor; some good. Kind of mystified why didn’t bring back Keller but passing on Pomeranz and Kittridge looks smart now. Maton has been a bust so far and that has hurt.
Cubs bullpen ERA was #5 and #6 in NL last two seasons. Not bad.
#8 so far in 2026—middle of the pack. Maton has a lot to do with that.