I remember the big knock coming out on Nicks was his speed. And I've pretty much come to the conclusion that straight line speed is really overrated when it comes to WRs. Especially when you're facing pass rushes that barely give your QB 3 seconds to get the ball out anyway. I mean yeah, Hester's fast but how far has that gotten him as a WR? Same with DeShaun Jackson.
What's more important than speed per se is the ability to separate from coverage, i.e., open up a window for your QB to get you the ball. We haven't had a big WR that can do that consistently for... well... pretty much forever.
The good news is, this draft is chock full of WRs who are exactly like Nicks. Big, strong guys with good hands who will never turn more than about a 4.5 in shorts but are gonna make plenty of catches on Sundays for the next few years for the teams smart enough to look past the 40 and pick them up. There is more value at the WR position in this draft, right down to the 3rd round, then there has been in years and I hope our new GM is smart enough to take advantage.